The Controversial 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken Baseball Card: A Story of Mistakes and Redemption

1989 Fleer Billy Ripken "Face" Card

In the world of baseball card collecting, certain cards have achieved legendary status due to their rarity, unique features, or errors. One such card is the 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken baseball card, which became infamous for an unexpected expletive printed on its bat. This curious variation sparked a whirlwind of controversy, captivating the sports memorabilia community and leaving the card’s manufacturer, Fleer, scrambling to correct the mistake. Let’s delve into the fascinating story of how this unexpected error occurred and the steps Fleer took to rectify the situation.

The Mistake

The 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken card featured the Baltimore Orioles’ infielder holding a baseball bat. However, on a specific variation of the card, the knob of the bat displayed a handwritten expletive, making it one of the most controversial and sought-after cards in the history of baseball card collecting. The word, which is beyond the scope of repeating in this article, was an unfortunate prank by Billy Ripken himself.

How the Mistake Happened

To understand how this unusual mistake occurred, we must trace the card’s origin back to the production process. It is crucial to note that in 1989, baseball cards were printed using a combination of photography and lithography techniques. The initial photographs were taken of the players, and then the negatives were used to print the cards. Subsequently, the player’s names and other details were added on top of the image.

In Billy Ripken’s case, during the photoshoot, he held a bat with the controversial word scribbled on it as a practical joke meant only for the eyes of his teammates and friends. Ripken expected the card to be airbrushed or edited before it went to print, assuming that his prank would remain a private inside joke. Unfortunately, this did not happen, and the unaltered image made its way to the printing press.

Fleer’s Response and Correction

Upon discovering the error, Fleer swiftly reacted to the controversy surrounding the Billy Ripken card. The company took several measures to rectify the situation and ensure the card’s replacement with a more suitable version.

Card Recall: Fleer promptly recalled the error variation of the Billy Ripken card from the market, attempting to prevent further distribution of the offensive version.

Correction: To avoid printing another set of cards entirely, Fleer devised a clever solution. They covered the offending word with a black box, effectively obscuring it from view. This modified version was quickly reproduced and sent out as a replacement for the original error card, but not before at least two other corrections were tried – one with a “black scribble” over the offending text and another version with white scribble or “White Out” over the bat handle.

There also exists a variation of the card with the original expletive shown but also with a deep cut into the bottom of the card. These so-called “sawcut” variations may have been an attempt by the factory to destroy its remaining inventory of offensive variations before disposing of them, in order to prevent the cards from being resold to collectors. As it turns out, the damaged variation is a sought-after collectibles on today’s market.

The Aftermath

The 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken card with the expletive became a highly sought-after item among collectors due to its rarity. However, because of Fleer’s swift action in recalling and replacing the card, the offensive version remained relatively scarce.

Billy Ripken himself acknowledged the prank and expressed regret for his actions, realizing the magnitude of the mistake and the impact it had on the card-collecting community. He later went on to have a respectable baseball career, focusing on his performance rather than the controversy surrounding the card.

The 1989 Fleer Billy Ripken baseball card variation with the expletive serves as a unique and unforgettable chapter in the history of sports memorabilia. It stands as a testament to the complexities of the production process and the potential for unforeseen errors. Fleer’s timely response and corrective actions demonstrated their commitment to maintaining the integrity of their product.

Today, the card remains a significant collector’s item, with both versions holding a special place in the hearts of avid baseball card enthusiasts. The story of the Billy Ripken card serves as a reminder that even mistakes can become valuable pieces of history and cherished tokens of a bygone era in the world of sports and collectibles.

    Billy Ripken 1989 Fleer Error Card


See the FIRST PREVIEW GALLERIES of our upcoming trading card products and new releases, receive EXCLUSIVE DISCOUNT OFFERS and keep in touch with the Repacked Wax team.

More To Explore

In 2020, Repacked Wax pioneered the concept of vintage cards repacked in old-school wax wrappers, just like you remember. Our packs let you rip vintage stars, commons, inserts, autographs and more from the 1950s to today at a more affordable price than most classic wax packs.